BLOG MAILING LIST
FOLLOW FEEDS
BOOK VIRTUAL CONSULTATION
ALTERNATIVE BILLING OPTIONS (LEGAL SERVICES)
LAW BLOGS
FIRM WEBSITE
PERSONAL WEBSITE
WHY AUDIT KEY CUSTOMER AGREEMENTS IN SLUGGISH ECONOMY
BLOG POST ARCHIVES
SUPPORT THIS BLOG
RECENT ARTICLES
- California Enacts New Law to Apply to Consumer Subscriptions
- Kristie Prinz to Lead New Silicon Valley Home Group in ProVisors
- Kristie Prinz to Speak at Upcoming Practicing Law Institute Program
- Software Lawyer Kristie Prinz Introduces The Prinz Law Office
- Kristie Prinz Explains Why to Review Your Key Customer Contracts in a Sluggish Economy
- Kristie Prinz Explains Why Not to Use the Term “SaaS License”
- Revisiting Your Software Company’s Most Important Customer Contracts in a Sluggish Economy
- SaaS Lawyer Kristie Prinz Selected to 2024 Super Lawyers Northern California List
- The Prinz Law Office Announces the Launch of New Services Offerings Effective August 1, 2024
- Kristie Prinz to Speak on Negotiating SaaS Contracts in an Uncertain Economy
- What are the Software Contracting Lessons to be Learned from Today’s Worldwide Technology Disruption?
- Introduction to Software and SaaS Lawyer Kristie Prinz
- Should Your Company Rethink its Software Subscription?
- FTC Proposes “Click to Cancel” Rule Provision for Recurring Subscriptions and Memberships
- FTC Files Lawsuit Against Adobe over Annual Paid Monthly Subscription Software Model
- California Considers Adoption of SB1047, Safe and Secure Innovation for Frontier Artificial Intelligence Models Act
- The Prinz Law Office Announces Launch of New Subscription Plans
- New California Law to Mandate Release of VC Investment Diversity Information
- Silicon Valley Arbitration and Mediation Center Publishes Guidelines on Use of Artificial Intelligence in Arbitration
- Talk with an Expert Series: Beau Fernald Shares Software Implementation Best Practices
- FTC Announces Settlement with Twitter Over Deceptive Use of Account Security Data
- Arbitration vs. Litigation: Which is Better for a SaaS Contract?
- Introduction to Silicon Valley Software Law Blog
- Introductory Digital Health Contracts Workshop for Lawyers
- Introduction to Software Contracts Workshop for Lawyers
- Intro to Digital Health Contracts for Non-Lawyers
- Intro to Software Contracts for Non-Lawyers
- Introduction to Negotiating and Drafting SaaS Contracts
- SaaS Lawyer Kristie Prinz to Present on Negotiating Digital Health Contracts
- Can software be subject to FDA regulation?
- Silicon Valley SaaS Lawyer Kristie Prinz’s Webinar on “Best Practices for Drafting and Negotiating SaaS Contracts” Now Available
- Silicon Valley SaaS Lawyer Kristie Prinz to Speak on “Best Practices for Drafting & Negotiating SaaS Contracts”
- Why “SaaS Agreements” are not “SaaS Licenses”
- The Prinz Law Office Adopts New Fixed & Subscription Billing Options
- Negotiating Consulting Services Agreements in an Uncertain Economy
- Introduction to Negotiating & Drafting SaaS Agreements
- Best Practices for Negotiating SaaS Agreements in an Uncertain Economy
- Silicon Valley Software Law Blog’s Kristie Prinz to Present Webinar on “Introduction to Negotiating & Drafting SaaS Agreements”
- Silicon Valley Software Law Blog’s Kristie Prinz to Present Webinar on “Best Practices for Negotiating SaaS Agreements in an Uncertain Economy”
- Best Practices for Negotiating SaaS Agreements in an Uncertain Economy
- The Intersection of Technology and Legal Practice: Addressing Current Technology Issues without Allowing Them to Overwhelm Your Practice
- Best Practices for Negotiating Development Agreements in an Uncertain Economy
- Accessing Coronavirus Disaster Aid to Sustain Your Software Company Through the Crisis
- Best Practices for Negotiating Master Services Agreements in an Uncertain Economy
- Best Practices for Negotiating SaaS Contracts & Managing SaaS Customer Relationships
- Force Majeure and the Coronavirus Pandemic: What Does Your Software Company Need to Know?
- Practice Tips for Renegotiating Contracts due to Coronavirus Uncertainty and Changed Business Conditions
- Capitalizing on SaaS Sales Opportunities During the Coronavirus Crisis Without Creating New Legal Risks
- Silicon Valley Software Law Blog’s Kristie Prinz to Present Series of Webinars On Negotiating in Uncertain Times
- Silicon Valley Software Law Blog’s Kristie Prinz to Present on “The Intersection of Law & Technology: Addressing Current Technology Issues without allowing them to Overwhelm Your Practice”
- Silicon Valley Software Law Blog’s Kristie Prinz to Present on “Negotiating SaaS Contracts & Managing Customer Relationships”
- Silicon Valley Software Law Blog’s Kristie Prinz to Speak on “Negotiating SaaS Agreements” for Clear Law Institute
- The Prinz Law Office Announces New Alternative Billing Options for 2020
- Last Minute Tips for Procrastinators: What Your Company Needs to Know about the January 1, 2020 Effective Date of the California Consumer Privacy Act (“CCPA”)
- Legal Developments Impacting the Software Industry 2019
- California Passes New Data Broker Law In Anticipation of January 1, 2020 Effective Date of California Consumer Privacy Act (“CCPA”)
- Silicon Valley Software Law Blog Author Kristie Prinz to Present Upcoming Webinar on “Legal Developments Impacting the Software Industry 2019”
- California Finalizes California Consumer Privacy Act (“CCPA”) In Anticipation of January 1st, 2020 Effective Date
- Best Practices for Negotiating SaaS Contracts & Managing SaaS Customer Relationships
- Silicon Valley Software Blog Law’s Kristie Prinz to Present Webinar on “Best Practices for Negotiating SaaS Contracts”
- Is a Company Liable for Software Defects, when a Vulnerability is Discovered but Not Exploited? A Recent Cisco Settlement Suggests Liability May Be Assessed
- Can Your Company Be Sued Over a Software Update? Tesla Suit Signals New Trend in Class Action Suits
- Private Coalition of Health Insurers and Major Tech Companies Announce New Standard for Claims Data Sharing
- Software Industry Concerned About the Potential Impact of AB-5 on Gig Economy
- Facebook Agrees to Record $5 Billion Settlement with FTC on Privacy Practices
- Should Law Enforcement Agencies’ Use of Facial Recognition Software Be Subject to Regulation?
- Silicon Valley Software Law Blog’s Kristie Prinz to Speak on Upcoming Webinar on SaaS Contracts
- Silicon Valley Software Law Blog’s Kristie Prinz to Present Upcoming Webinar on Software Hosting Agreements
- FTC Puts Software Companies and Service Providers on Notice of Broad Enforcement Powers Under Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act Safeguards Rule
- FTC Sends Warning to IoT Companies on the Importance of Secure Software Development with Enforcement Action Against D-Link
- Developers File Suit Against Apple for App Store Practices Following Recent Decision by U.S. Supreme Court
- Supreme Court Rules Against Apple in Antitrust Case to Determine if App Store is Monopoly
- The Prinz Law Office Announces Opening of New San Francisco Office
- Best Practices for Drafting Master Service Agreements & Managing the Service Relationship
- Best Practices for Drafting SaaS Contracts
- Silicon Valley Software Law Blog’s Kristie Prinz to Speak on “Best Practices for Drafting Master Service Agreements & Managing the Service Relationship”
- Silicon Valley Software Law’s Kristie Prinz to Speak on “Best Practices for Drafting SaaS Contracts & Managing SaaS Customer Relationships”
- The Prinz Law Office Opens New Palo Alto Office
- The Anticipated Impact of The Foreign Investment Risk Review Modernization Act of 2018 (“FIRRMA”) on the Software Industry
- Software Industry Warns of Fallout from Australia’s Passage of New Anti-Encryption Legislation
FTC Files Lawsuit Against Adobe over Annual Paid Monthly Subscription Software Model
Listen to Audio Version of Text
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Consumer-facing SaaS and software companies are on notice by the FTC that their subscription billing practices are under scrutiny. The FTC has just filed a lawsuit against Adobe over its “Annual Paid Monthly” subscription model, which the FTC says in its consumer alert “put subscribers on the hook for a whole year of payments, paid in monthly increments” without proper explanation or disclosure. A copy of the FTC complaint is attached here.
What subscription practices with the “Annual Paid Monthly” subscription plan did the FTC find particularly objectionable?
According to the FTC, Adobe enrolled consumers by default in its most expensive plan without clearly disclosing the key terms of the plan, which were that they were agreeing to a year-long commitment with a large early termination fee, and that consumers only discovered the nature of what they agreed to when they tried to terminate and realized they could not do so without incurring a significant fee. The FTC stated:
Adobe hides material terms of its [Annual Paid Monthly] plan in fine print and behind optional textboxes and hyperlinks, providing disclosures that are designed to go unnoticed and that most consumers never see. Adobe then deters cancellations by employing an onerous and complicated cancellation process. As part of this convoluted process, Adobe ambushes subscribers with the previously obscured ETF when they attempt to cancel.
What is particularly significant about the FTC’s actions is that the FTC not only filed suit against the corporation Adobe but it also filed suit individually against two of its executives. The FTC is demanding monetary civil penalties against Defendants and a permanent injunction as well as other damages.
What is the basis of the FTC’s legal case against Adobe? The FTC’s case focuses on The Restore Online Shopper’s Confidence Act, 15 U.S.C. §§ 8401-8405 (“ROSCA”). The text of ROSCA is published here. ROSCA prohibits unfair and deceptive Internet sales practices, and generally prohibits charging consumers for goods and services sold in transactions through a negative option feature unless the seller:
- clearly and conspicuously discloses all material terms of the transactions before obtaining billing information from the consumer
- obtains the consumer’s express informed consent before making the charge
- provides simple mechanisms to stop recurring charges.
The FTC alleges Adobe had significantly increased its revenue by engaging in practices that violated ROSCA.
What are the SaaS and software contracting best practices to be learned from this FTC action?
First and foremost, you should rethink the use of “Annual Paid Monthly” Subscription Plans. They may seem clever from a marketing perspective, but they are likely to draw heavy regulatory scrutiny going forward.
Second of all, if you are offering “Annual Paid Monthly” subscription plans, you should go out of your way to clearly and conspicuously disclose the key terms of your “Annual Paid Monthly” plan, including in particular the key facts that the plan has an annual subscription term and that it has an early termination fee. You also should be exceedingly clear about the price of the early termination fee.
Third of all, if you are offering “Annual Paid Monthly” subscription plans, you should refrain from taking steps in the customer enrollment process to push your customers to the “Annual Paid Monthly” subscription plan.
Fourth, if you are offering “Annual Paid Monthly” subscription plans, you should make it easy for your customers to cancel. If customers are posting online complaints about the problems they have had in trying to cancel your subscription, you should take action prompt action to address those problems. It seems clear that the FTC was troubled by the complaints posted with the better business bureau against Adobe on this issue.
Finally, if you are a SaaS or software company, you need to become familiar with ROSCA and the government’s ROSCA enforcement practices, if it was not already on your company’s radar.
The Silicon Valley Software Law Blog will continue to advise you of the developments with this FTC action as it moves forward. If you have questions or concerns about FTC compliance generally or this action in particular, please reach out and schedule a consultation with me at this link.
Blog Author: Kristie Prinz
Read Moreloading ...
NETWORKING GROUPS
WHY NOT TO USE TERM “SAAS LICENSE”
SHOULD YOUR COMPANY RETHINK ITS SUBSCRIPTION TERMS?
LESSONS TO BE LEARNED FROM CROWDSTRIKE INCIDENT
UPCOMING LIVE PROGRAMS
Coming soon!
RECORDED WEBINARS
- Best Practices for Negotiating and Drafting SaaS Contracts (November 2021)
- Negotiating SaaS Contracts & Managing Customer Relationships (March 2020)
- Best Practices for Negotiating SaaS Contracts (Oct. 2019)
- Best Practices for Drafting MSAs (2019)
- Legal Developments in Software Industry (2019)
- Best Practices for Drafting SaaS Contracts (October. 2017)
- Best Practices for Drafting SaaS Contracts that Reduce the Sales Cycle & Avoid Disputes (March 2017)
- What You Need to Know About Nondisclosure Agreements (2009)
- What Every Small Business Needs to Know About IP (2009)
- Leveraging an IP Portfolio (2009)
- What Companies Should Know About Business Blogging (Sept. 2009)
- Social and Professional Online Networking (2009)
- Developments and Trends in Blog Law (2009)
- How to Protect Against the Risks of Workers Going Online (2008)
TOPICS
- AI Regulation
- Announcements
- Antitrust Regulation
- App Store Changes
- Artificial Intelligence
- California Privacy Legislation
- California Regulation
- Criminal Investigation
- Data Breach
- Development Tips
- Digital Health
- Dispute Resolution
- Employment Litigation
- EU Regulation
- FCC Regulation
- FDA Regulation
- FTC Regulation
- Internet Legislation
- Litigation
- ON-DEMAND PROGRAMS
- Patent Litigation
- PRESENTATIONS
- Privacy Shield
- Publications
- Small Business Legislation
- Smartphone Applications
- Software Agreement Drafting
- Software Controversies
- Software Crimes
- software implementation
- Software Legislation
- Software Litigation
- Software Start-up Tips
- Start-up Software Company
- State Regulation
- Talk with an Expert Series
- Uncategorized
- Upcoming Event Notice
- UPCOMING LIVE PROGRAMS
- Upcoming Speaking Engagements
- US Privacy Legislation
- Video
POPULAR POSTS
- Software Licensing vs. Software-as-a-Service…
- What SaaS Companies Need to Know About Source Code…
- Why “SaaS Agreements” are not…
- Service Level Agreements: What is a Service-Level…
- Arbitration vs. Litigation: Which is Better for a…
- Negotiating the Purchase of SaaS Company Assets: Key…
- FTC Puts Software Companies and Service Providers on…
- What Software Companies Need to Know about the EU…
- Apple Signals New Enforcement Strategy to Companies…
- Websites Set to Observe SOPA Blackout Day
- Can software be subject to FDA regulation?
- Silicon Valley Arbitration and Mediation Center…
- California Enacts New Law to Apply to Consumer Subscriptions
- New California Law to Mandate Release of VC…
- Introduction to Silicon Valley Software Law Blog
- Digital Rights Management Software and the Printer…
- Recent FTC Enforcement Action Should Serve as…
- Recent Software Class Actions Provide Valuable…
- Investigation Reportedly Launched by Department of…
- Facebook Agrees to Record $5 Billion Settlement with…
- California Finalizes California Consumer Privacy Act…
- California Passes New Data Broker Law In…
- Talk with an Expert Series: Beau Fernald Shares…
- Does Your Customer Software License or SaaS…
- In Aftermath of GDPR, California Passes Consumer…
- FTC Announces Settlement with Twitter Over Deceptive…
- California Considers Adoption of SB1047, Safe and…
- Recent FTC Enforcement Actions Should Serve as…
- FTC Proposes “Click to Cancel” Rule…
- Introduction to Software Contracts Workshop for Lawyers
- Careful Drafting of Pricing Terms is Key to all…
- Common Software Agreement Fee Drafting Problems and…
- FTC Files Lawsuit Against Adobe over Annual Paid…
- Microsoft Launches New Constitutional Challenge…
- Is the OPEN Act a More Viable Alternative to SOPA?
- Irish Court Has Referred Case to European Court…
- Software Industry Warns of Fallout from…
- Intro to Software Contracts for Non-Lawyers
- Should Your Software Company Be Concerned about…
- Silicon Valley SaaS Lawyer Kristie Prinz’s…
- Is a Company Liable for Software Defects, when a…
- Accessing Coronavirus Disaster Aid to Sustain Your…
- Silicon Valley SaaS Lawyer Kristie Prinz to Speak on…
- Technology and Telecommunication Companies Lobby…
- Are “Unethical” App Subscription…
- Silicon Valley Software Law Blog’s Kristie…
- Introduction to Negotiating and Drafting SaaS Contracts
- SaaS Lawyer Kristie Prinz to Present on Negotiating…
- Supreme Court Rules Against Apple in Antitrust Case…
- California to Consider Bill that Restores Net Neutrality
DIGITAL HEALTH LAW BLOG
SAAS CONTRACTS LAW BLOG
- SaaS Companies Must Comply with California Subscription Law
- Kristie Prinz to Lead New Silicon Valley Group in ProVisors
- Kristie Prinz Introduces The Prinz Law Office
- SaaS Contracts Lawyer Kristie Prinz Speaks on Why to Audit Key Customer Contracts in a Sluggish Economy
- SaaS Contracts Lawyer Kristie Prinz Speaks on Why Not to Use the Term “SaaS License”
- Will Customer Cost-Cutting Affect Your SaaS Company?
- SaaS Contracts Lawyer Kristie Prinz Selected as 2024 Super Lawyer California
- The Prinz Law Office Announces New Service Offerings Effective August 1, 2024
- Kristie Prinz to Speak on Negotiating SaaS Contracts in an Uncertain Economy
- What are the Lessons to be Learned from Today’s Worldwide Tech Failure Over a Software Update?